Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

logo

  • a plate of food
    Slide 1 of 7
  • a dining room table
    Slide 2 of 7
  • a close up of a wine glass
    Slide 3 of 7
  • a sandwich sitting on top of a wooden table
    Slide 4 of 7
  • a cup of tea sitting on top of a wooden table
    Slide 5 of 7
  • a plate of food with broccoli
    Slide 6 of 7
  • a glass of beer on a table
    Slide 7 of 7

    • Hours & Location

    10 W. Grand Ave.,
    Lake Villa, IL 60046
    (847) 979-0600

    HOURS
    Mon - Tues: CLOSED

    Wed: 11:30AM - 9:00PM

    Thur: 11:30AM-10PM

    Fri - Sat: 11:30AM - 11PM

    Sun: 11:30AM - 9:00PM

    KITCHEN HOURS
    Mon - Tues: CLOSED

    Wed: 11:30AM - 8:00PM

    Thur: 11:30AM-9PM

    Fri - Sat: 11:30AM - 10:00PM

    Sun: 11:30AM - 8:00PM

    Get Directions

    Menus

    *Denotes our Favorites

    Starters

    • *O'Toole's Famous Wings

      BBQ, mild, spicy, buffalo, Irish ghost, garlic parm, garlic ginger, chipotle BBQ, honey sriracha, volcanic 2.0 & sweet Thai chile

      1 LB. $13

      2 LB. $26

      3 LB. $39

      5 LB. $65

    • Boneless Wings

      Tossed in your choice of wing sauce

      Half Pound $9

      Full Pound $13

    • Chicken Fingers

      5 breaded chicken fingers served plain with your choice of dipping sauce

      $12

    • Saucy Fingers

      5 breaded chicken fingers served tossed in your favorite wing sauce

      $13

    • *Reuben Egg Rolls

      Corned beef, jack cheese, sauerkraut, caraway seeds & spicy mustard; side of thousand island

      $10

    • Pretzel Trio

      Deep fried pretzels, beer cheese fondue, IPA mustard & Guinness honey mustard

      $11

    • Chips, Salsa & Guacamole

      House made served with warm tortilla chips

      $10

    • Nachos

      Tortilla chips, black beans or chili, tomato, three cheese blend, house pickled jalapeños, scallions, salsa & sour cream

      $12

      Add grilled chicken $4

      Add guacamole $3

    • *Irish Nachos

      French fries, three cheese blend, bacon, scallions & sour cream

      $13

    • Mozzarella Sticks

      8 deep fried mozzarella sticks served with marinara sauce

      $10

    • Baked Goat Cheese

      Warm marinara sauce & garlic bread

      $10

    • French Fries Appetizer

      Select Cajun, truffle or garlic parmesan, served with ranch dressing

      $6

    • Dill Pickle Fries

      breaded and fried pickles served with chipotle aioli

      $11

    Sandwiches

    Served with choice of fries, chips. tots or coleslaw

    • *Classic Reuben

      Local corned beef, Swiss, thousand island & sauerkraut on marbled rye

      $15

    • French Dip

      Shaved beef, mozzarella & horseradish sauce

      $15

    • Honey Sriracha Chicken

      Baja slaw, jalapeño jack cheese & garlic aioli on a pretzel bun

      $15

    • California Club

      Turkey, avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli

      $14

    • Bacon Turkey Avocado Cheddar Melt

      michigan turkey, applewood smoked bacon, cheddar, avocado, tomato, guinness honey mustard on grilled tuscan bread

      $15

    • Jerk Chicken

      Pineapple relish, avocado, baja slaw, jalapeño jack cheese

      $15

    • Roost Chicken

      all natural grilled chicken breast, guinness honey mustard swiss cheese, pickles

      $14

    • Roast Beef BBQ Melt

      roast beef, cheddar cheese, fried onion strings, chipotle aioli, bbq drizzle on parmesan crusted grilled tuscan bread

      $16

    • Blazing Buffalo Fried Chicken

      irish ghost wing sauce, american cheese. (bleu cheese or ranch dressings on the side)

      $15

    Burgers

    Half-pound burger, chicken, beyond burger (plant-based +$2 upcharge). Sub gluten-free bun +$1.5. Served with choice of fries, chips or tots

    • O'Toole's Original

      Cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle

      $13

    • Tiny Tim

      1/3 lb. O'Toole's Original Burger

      $11

    • Bacon Cheese

      Bacon and cheddar cheese

      $14

    • *Chicago Fire

      Bacon, fried egg, avocado, cheddar & irish ghost wing sauce on a pretzel bun

      $17

    • Speakeasy

      Applewood smoked bacon, bleu cheese & garlic aioli

      $15

    • Mushroom & Swiss

      Sautéed mushrooms & Swiss cheese

      $14

    • Patty Melt

      American cheese, grilled onions, marbled rye bread

      $14

    • All American

      Blackened burger, applewood smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, thousand island

      $14

    • Chipotle Avocado

      bacon, avocado, jalapeño jack cheese, chipotle aioli

      $16

    • *Little Timmy

      Cheddar, jalapeño jack, mozzarella, swiss, bacon, bbq & fried onion strings. lettuce, tomato, onion & pickles

      $18

    • Big Timmy Challenge

      As seen on Man VS Food | 2 1/2 lb. burger patties, cheddar, jalapeño jack, mozzarella, swiss, bacon, fried onion strings, bbq, lettuce, tomato, pickle, & red onion. served with irish nachos

      $28

    Rice Bowls

    Add chicken +$7; add shrimp +$7; add salmon +$11

    • Burrito Bowl

      Rice, black beans, avocado, pico de gallo, three cheese blend & cilantro-lime crema

      $11

    • Keto Bowl

      Riced cauliflower, gremolata, goat cheese, baja slaw, pico de gallo & avocado

      $13

    • Teriyaki Bowl

      Sticky rice, broccoli, red peppers, pineapple, sesame seeds & fried wontons

      $11

    • *Caribbean Bowl

      Rice, black beans, jerk chicken, pineapple relish, avocado & lime

      $17

    Desserts

    • Chocolate Walnut Brownie***

      Walnut chocolate brownie, ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate and caramel sauce. ***Contains Nuts

      $6

    • Pretzel Bread Pudding

      Caramel sauce & whipped cream

      $6

    Greens & Wraps

    Wraps served with choice of (fries, tots, chips or coleslaw). Add chicken +$7; add shrimp +$7; add salmon +$11

    • *Michigan Avenue

      Mixed greens, goat cheese, corn, craisins, avocado, almonds, tomato, croutons & citrus vinaigrette

      Entrée $10

      Wrap $10

    • Caesar

      Romaine, croutons, shaved parmesan & caesar dressing

      Entrée $9

      Wrap $9

    • BBQ Ranch Chicken

      Crispy or grilled chicken, mixed greens, tomato, three cheese blend, fried onion strings, BBQ sauce & ranch

      Entrée $15

      Wrap $15

    • Buffalo Chicken

      Crispy or grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, crumbled bleu cheese, tomato, celery, croutons & ranch

      Entrée $15

      Wrap $15

    • Cobb

      arcadian greens, avocado, egg, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, bacon, scallions, choice of dressing

      Entrée $11

      Wrap $11

    • Southern Fried Chicken Salad

      romaine lettuce, shredded cheese, fried chicken, corn, almonds, tomatoes, croutons, guinness honey mustard

      Entrée $15

      Wrap $15

    Baskets

    Served with choice of french fries

    • *Wing Basket

      1 lb. bone-in wings tossed in your choice of sauce: BBQ, mild, spicy, buffalo, Irish ghost, garlic parm, garlic ginger, chipotle BBQ, honey sriracha, volcanic 2.0 & sweet Thai chile

      $15

    • Boneless Wings Basket

      1/2 lb. boneless wings tossed in your choice of sauce

      $11

    • Chicken Fingers Basket

      4 breaded chicken fingers served plain with your choice of dipping sauce: BBQ, honey mustard, ranch, bleu cheese & buffalo

      $13

      Tossed in favorite wing sauce $1

    • Rib Basket

      1/2 lb slab Wichita baby back ribs smothered in Chicago style BBQ sauce

      $14

    Tacos

    2 tacos served with black beans & rice, served on corn tortillas

    • Blackened Chicken

      Avocado, pico de gallo & cilantro lime crema

      $13

    • Blackened Salmon

      Pico de gallo, jalapeño aioli & baja slaw

      $15

    • Shrimp

      Grilled shrimp, sweet Thai chile, cilantro & pineapple relish

      $14

    • *Baja Fish

      Beer battered cod, baja slaw, pico de gallo & jalapeño aioli

      $13

    Entrées

    • *Fish & Chips

      3 pieces smithwick’s hand battered haddock served with fries, tartar sauce, coleslaw, lemon

      $17

    • Faroe Island Salmon

      grilled salmon, mashed potatoes, veggies (available blackened, bbq, teriyaki or plain)

      $20

    • Mac & Cheese

      Four cheese blend served with garlic bread

      $14

    • Country Fried Chicken Mac & Cheese

      four cheese blend with crispy chicken breast, drizzled with bbq or buffalo wing sauce. served with garlic bread

      $16

    • Bayou Mac & Cheese

      Four cheeses, chicken, andouille sausage, peas & mushrooms

      $15

      Sub Shrimp $19

    • Tuscan Pasta

      Bow tie pasta, goat cheese, sun-dried tomato, garlic, olive oil & fresh basil. Served with garlic bread

      $12

      Add chicken $7

      Add shrimp $7

      Add salmon $11

    • *Ribs

      Full slab of Wichita baby back ribs smothered in Chicago style BBQ sauce. Choice of side

      $20

    • Guinness Beef Stew

      beef braised with guinness, potatoes, peas, aromatics, mashed potatoes, house made irish soda bread

      $16

    Soups & Side Dishes

    • French Onion Soup

      Crock $8

      Cup $5

    • Chili

      Cup $3.50

      Bowl $5.50

    • French Fries

      $4

    • Tater Tots

      $4

    • Potato Chips

      $4

    • Black Beans & Rice

      $4

    • 4oz Coleslaw

      $4

    • Small Salad or Caesar Salad

      $5

    • Steamed Broccoli

      $5

    • Fresh Veggies

      $5

    Kids Options

    Served with choice of fries, chips, tots or veggies and choice of soft drink or apple juice

    • Noodles

      With choice of marinara or butter

      $8

    • Chicken Fingers

      Breaded chicken fingers served with choice of Mild, Buffalo, BBQ, chipotle BBQ, Ranch or Bleu Cheese

      $9

    • Hamburger or Cheeseburger

      Choice of plain or with your choice of cheese. Add toppings with additional charge

      $9

    • Grilled Cheese

      White bread & American cheese

      $6

    • Mac & Cheese

      Three cheese blend

      $9

    • O'Toole's Boneless Wings

      Mild, Buffalo, Garlic Parm, BBQ, chipotle BBQ, Ranch or Bleu Cheese

      $9

    Download PDF
    Download PDF

    Timothy O'Toole's Lake Villa has a great selection of craft beer, cocktails and great happy hour specials.

    Timothy O'Toole's Lake Villa has a great selection of craft beer, cocktails and great happy hour specials.

    SIGNATURE COCKTAILS

    • BIG TULLY

      Tullamore D.E.W Irish Whiskey, ginger ale, fresh lemon & lime

    • O'TOOLE'S BLOODY MARY

      O’Toole’s Vodka, O’Toole’s Bloody Mary Mix, Celery Salt Rim, Olive, Lime, Lemon & Pickle Spear

    • IRISH MULE

      Jameson Irish Whiskey, ginger beer, fresh lime

    • JOLLY RANCHER MARTINI

      O’Toole’s Vodka, apple or watermelon, splash sour

    • O'TOOLE'S HOLY WATER

      Our signature recipe of 12 liquors and 3 fruit juices

    • BORDEAUX MARTIN

      O’Toole’s Vodka, Lillet Rose, St. Germain, lemon juice, simple syrup, garnished with a lemon peel twist

    • PRICKLY PEAR MARGARITA

      Casamigos Blanco Tequila, desert pear syrup, Organic Sour, lime

    • THUNDER PUNCH

      Bacardi Silver, orange juice peach & pineapple, grenadine

    CLASSIC COCKTAILS

    • MANHATTAN

      Four Roses Bourbon, Carpano Antica, dark & orange bitters

    • MOJITO

      Bacardi Silver, simple syrup, soda, mint, lime

    • OLD FASHIONED

      Four Roses Bourbon, demerara syrup, orange & cherry bitters

    • O'TOOLE'S MULE

      O’Toole’s Vodka, ginger beer, lime

    • O'TOOLE'S SIGNATURE MARGARITA

      Tres Agaves Blanco Tequila, Triple Sec, Organic Sour, lime

    • SANGRIA

      Choice Of Red Or White Sangria. Topped With Seasonal Fruits

    • CUCUMBER BLOODY MARY

      Effen Cucumber Vodka, O'Toole’s Bloody Mix, Cucumber Slice

    • THE AVIATION

      Bombay Gin, Creme De Violette, Luxardo Maraschino Cherry Liqueur, lemon juice, garnished with a cherry

    Timothy O'Toole's Lake Villa has a great selection of craft beer, cocktails and great happy hour specials.

    WEDNESDAY - #WINESDAY

    • Sangria Carafe

      $20

    • House Wine By the Glass

      $7

    • Whipped Feta

      with local honey, black pepper and pita bread

      $13

    • Pretzel Bread Pudding

      $5

    FAN FAVE FRIDAY

    • Shot of the Day

      $5

    THROWBACK THURSDAY

    • Select Craft Cans

      $5

    • Deviled Eggs

      $6

    • 4 ROSES OLD FASHIONED OR MANHATTAN

      $8

    • Garlic Parmesan Pretzels

      $6

    SOCIAL SATURDAY

    • Beer of the Month

      $5

    • Sparkling Rosé or Champagne

      $6

    • Shot of the Day

      $5

    SUNDAY FUNDAY

    • BYO Bloody Mary Bar

      $8

    • BYO Mimosa Bar

      $6

    • Miller Lite Jumbo Mugs

      $5

    • Fried Pickles

      $6

    Timothy O'Toole's Lake Villa has a great selection of craft beer, cocktails and great happy hour specials.

    WHITE WINES

    • BROKEN EARTH CHARDONNAY

      CALIFORNIA

    • BOGLE SAUVIGNON BLANC

      CALIFORNIA

    • KIM CRAWFORD SAUVIGNON BLANC

      NEW ZEALAND

    • KUNG FU RIESLING

      WASHINGTON

    • RUFFINO PINOT GRIGIO

      ITALY

    • SEVEN DAUGHTERS MOSCATO

      ITALY

    • CHARLES & CHARLES ROSÉ

      CALIFORNIA

    • TERRA D'ORO PINOT GRIGIO

      CALIFORNIA

    RED WINES

    • BOGLE PINOT NOIR

      CALIFORNIA

    • MEIOMI PINOT NOIR

      CALIFORNIA

    • BOGLE MERLOT

      CALIFORNIA

    • BROKEN EARTH CABERNET

      CALIFORNIA

    • CHASING LIONS CABERNET

      CALIFORNIA

    • HIGH NOTE MALBEC

      ARGENTINA

    • FERRARI-CARANO SIENA (RED BLEND)

      CALIFORNIA

    SPARKLING

    • KORBEL SPLIT

    • VEUVE CLICQUOT YELLOW LABEL

    • WYCLIFF BRUT

    • WYCLIFF ROSÉ

    Download PDF

    Crafted non-alcoholic beverages

    • BLUEBERRY ARNOLD PALMER

      lemonade, iced tea, blueberry lemon simple syrup, clapped mint, lemon wedge garnish

    • POMEGRANATE NOJITO

      lemonade, pomegranate syrup, simple syrup, lime juice, soda water, fresh lime garnish and mint leaves

    • STRAWBERRY LIME MARG

      organic strawberry mix, agave nectar, lemonade, cranberry juice, lime juice, lime wedge and mint sprig garnish

    • MANGO TANGO-RITA

      organic mango chili mix, OJ, lime juice, Tajin rim and deydrated orange garnish

    • COSNOPOLITAN

      Dragon Fruit Monin, cranberry juice, lime juice, OJ, soda, simple syrup, lemon peel garnish and edible flower

    • PINEAPPLE GINGER MULE

      organic pineapple ginger mix, ginger simple syrup, lime juice, pineapple juice, ginger beer and dehydrated lime garnish

    • BREEZE MOCKTAIL

      Peach Monin, Pomegranate Monin, lemonade, lime juice, cranberry juice, soda and garnished with an orange slice and flower

    Download PDF

    SEASONAL COCKTAILS

    • Peach Bourbon John Daly

      Four Roses Bourbon, simple syrup, peach schnapps, peach monin, lemonade with iced tea, garnished with a lemon wedge

    • Blueberry Açaí Mule

      Van Gogh Açaí Blueberry, lime juice, blueberry lemon simple syrup, topped with ginger beer, garnished with a lime wedge and mint sprig

    • Pina Colada Mule

      Captain Morgan, Malibu, lime juice, pineapple juice, ginger beer, garnished with a maraschino cherry and a dehydrated pineapple slice

    • Summer Spice Old Fashioned

      Four Roses Bourbon, Bada Bing Cherry Juice, Fee Bros Falernum, orange bitters, red bitters, garnished with a cherry

    • Grapefruit Fizz

      O’Toole's Vodka, Pamplemousse Liqueur, lime juice, grapefruit juice, splash of sprite, ginger beer, garnished with a lime wedge and edible flower

    • Orange Bourbon Crush

      Four Roses Bourbon, triple sec, ginger simple syrup, OJ, garnished with a dehydrated orange

    • Prickly Pear Margarita

      Tres Agaves Tequila, triple sec, Tres Agaves Mix, prickly pear monin syrup, agave nectar, lime juice, garnished with an orange slice and flower

    • Strawberry Rosa Margarita

      Calirosa Rosa Blanco Tequila, Lillet Rose, Tres Agaves Strawberry Mix, agave nectar, lime juice, garnished with a lime wedge and mint sprig

    • Mango Chili Margarita

      Tres Agaves Tequila, Tres Agaves Mango Chili Mix, triple sec, lime juice, garnished with a dehydrated lime slice and Tajin rim

    • Pineapple Ginger Margarita

      Calirosa Rosa Blanco Tequila, triple sec, Tres Agaves Pineapple Ginger Mix, pineapple juice, lime juice, ginger simple syrup, garnished with a dehydrated pineapple and lime wedge

    • Blueberry Cucumber Tonic

      Hendricks Gin, lemon juice, blueberry lemon simple syrup, tonic, garnished with a cucumber spiral and blueberries

    • Peach Paloma

      Tres Agaves Tequila, Pamplemousse Liqueur, peach monin, lime juice, agave nectar, frozen peach garnish and lime wedge

    Events

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!